I used to wear the Emily bag in burgundy smooth leather daily. Bought it in 2020 and only sold it last month. Nice leather quality​,​ the bag held up pretty well but the silver hardware started oxydizing at some point (maybe something to do with Paris' rainy weather ). It did get a few scratches but nothing too noticeable One downside would be that it doesn't fully close but that didn't bother me Imo​,​ They are really great for the price point. Easily one of the best brands in their price range I loved wearing it and still love seeing it worn by others. Pics of the bag right before I sold it in July 2024 (1st pic). Oxydation marks on the hardware (2nd pic).